Mobileread
GlowLight Plus vs GlowLight 3
#1  Catsnkites 01-18-2020, 11:30 PM
I didn't realize that any of the Nook eReaders had page turn buttons ... so, I've given up on converting my mother's Nook books and am looking into getting her a new Nook eReader.

I haven't used a Nook reader in many years.

I see on the B&N website that there are two (non-tablet) eReaders ... GlowLight Plus and GlowLight 3.

I can compare the pricing & specs, but my concern is the ratings.

The Plus is rated at 4 stars by 51 reviewers. The 3 is rated 2.5 stars by 177 reviewers.

The reviews can't be sorted ... usually I look at reviews in chronological order, since updates can make a so-so product better or a good product bad.

Anyway, could someone sort of "nut-shell" the issues with either or both of these readers?

Thank you!

Susie
Kansas
Reply 

#2  Sirtel 01-19-2020, 01:11 AM
The Glowlight 3 had various issues with slowness and sideloaded content vanishing. As I don't own the device, I have no idea if it's gotten better or not.

The Glowlight Plus has few problems. It's slower than Kobos or Kindles, but otherwise pretty stable. Some users have reported their sideloaded content vanishing like with the Glowlight 3, but there have not been many of those.

Personally I have over 1000 sideloaded books on my Glowlight Plus and I haven't noticed any issues. The trick is to use strictly Calibre for adding and deleting books, not load hundreds of books in one batch (better string them out, say 10 books in a batch, wait till the job's finished, then load another batch), eject the Nook from Calibre and not pull the plug until it's finished processing the books (you'll see the covers quickly alternating on the homescreen, don't disconnect until they've stopped).
Reply 

#3  Calenorn 01-19-2020, 06:16 AM
Let me emphasize what Sirtel said, DO NOT unplug the ereader from the PC too soon!

My PC shows a pop-up stating that it is safe to unplug the device. IT IS WRONG!!! Watch the ereader carefully. My Kobo allows me to check that the new books are accessible on the reader. Only then do I unplug it. I don't know if the NOOK will let you do that.

Unplugging the ereader while it is still transferring data will corrupt the database, and then things get messy.
Reply 

#4  Pajamaman 01-19-2020, 09:12 AM
The glowlight 3 and the glowlight plus 7.8" are quite similar except that the 3 is 6" and the plus is 7.8". Another difference is that the 3 has a slightly clearer screen because the touch system is infrared, wheres the plus is capacitive and so has an extra layer over the display. But both screens should be clear enough. It's not a biggie. A more important point is do you want a 7.8" screen to read books on? Many people find it too heavy and too large. If you mother's eyes are not great, then the 7.8" might be better so she can increase the font size. On the other hand, if her hands are weak, it might be too heavy.

Apart from that, the devices are fairly similar. There were issues with the Nook GL3 firmware, but I'm not sure it's still an issue, and I'm not sure the plus and the 3 even use different software now.

I have a GL3 and I really like it, but I have rooted it and put custom software on it. The screen is ultra clear. Best screen I've ever had.
Reply 

#5  Lparsons21 01-19-2020, 09:22 AM
I have a Glowlight Plus 7.8” and love it. Looked at both in the store and while there are differences in the screen, it is very slight IMO. I don’t know your mother’s age, but I’m 76 and find it not too big or heavy.




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
Reply 

#6  cgsmom 01-19-2020, 09:53 AM
I too have a GL+7.8 and I like if very much. I have sideloaded many books from Calibre with no problems whatsoever. I only load in small batches, about 10 - 20 at a time and I have had no problems. I have over 1500 books in my B&N account and almost that many from Amazon. Since I got used to the 7.8 inch screen, I find the 6 inch looks tiny. I have started using a slightly larger font size (getting older) and have no problem with the size and weight of the larger Nook.
Reply 

#7  Catsnkites 01-19-2020, 11:55 AM
One more question, everyone talks about sideloading with Calibre ... when I last used a Nook (as I said, years and years ago ... maybe the one with the color section at the bottom) ... anyway, I would check out books from the library and use Adobe Digital Editions to load them. Does that still work?

The eReader I use works with Overdrive and I can get about 80% of my library books when I do a sync. The rest I need to use ADE to load them.

Thank you for all the wonderful advice! This is way better than trying to wade though the reviews!

Susie
Kansas
Reply 

#8  Pajamaman 01-20-2020, 10:56 AM
I don't know if the Nook supports borrowing from libraries. I believe the Kobo and the Kindle supports it, but I am not sure. I am not in the USA. If library support is important, maybe ask what e-readers do it and how well in the What e-reader sub-section.
Reply 

#9  Sirtel 01-20-2020, 03:16 PM
I don't use libraries personally, but yes, the Nook should still support library books. AFAIK you can't borrow them directly on the device, you'll need ADE on your computer.
Reply 

#10  HLS 01-20-2020, 04:03 PM
I own both. I love the Plus. The screen is better than the regular glowlight. I own many kobos, kindles, nooks and The Plus is my favorite Nook so far.

I have no issues with sideloading or finding my sideloaded material. I experience no sluggishness at all.
Reply 

  Next »  Last »  (1/2)
Today's Posts | Search this Thread | Login | Register