Mobileread
Marvin 3.X: Sync annotations between ipad & iphone
#1  binone 07-22-2016, 11:31 AM
I read the same book on multiple devices (ipad & iphone).

The zero config page sync is a great new feature - thanks!

Question: Can I easily sync annotations between the two devices?

Use case 1:
Annotate on device 1.
Export (Marvin to Marvin) to device 2.

Expected outcome:
Annotations are synced on device 2?

Will annotations on device 1 be preserved or overwritten by those on device 2?

Use case 2:
Sync annotations via iCloud? Future?

Thanks for a great app!
Reply 

#2  binone 07-23-2016, 10:38 AM
Results of some testing.

If I copy annotations (marvin to marvin) option.

Existing highlights on device 2 are preserved.

Highlights from device 1 are added to journal only. The highlights do not get applied to book copy on device 2.

Possible bug: If from journal I click on the newly imported annotation, it takes me to an existing annotation on device 2 and not the location to which the imported annotation applies.

The current annotation handling makes the feature unusable across devices.
Reply 

#3  kguil 07-25-2016, 07:20 AM
@binone The highlights *should* be preserved. Please open he book on device 2 (the one that received the import), open the book, tap the contents button on top, and see if the annotations are there.
Reply 

#4  binone 07-26-2016, 11:47 AM
You are right!

I did the process very carefully this time and the annotations (highlights) did transfer over correctly to the same book on the second device. Existing annotations on the receiving device were also preserved.

Sweet.

I am not sure why it did not appear to work the first time I tried.

So the only (future) ask then is to have a way to transfer these via icloud.

Thanks again for taking the time to respond and for a great app.
Reply 

#5  Faterson 07-26-2016, 06:30 PM
Well, not necessarily via iCloud, perhaps Dropbox (or other cloud storage) would be a good option as well. Syncing of annotations, highlights and bookmarks in Marvin would definitely be a major breakthrough for Marvin – one we've been waiting for for nearly 5 years now. Marvin is, to me, the best iOS e-reader, hands down – but it cannot be called "great" software until it supports a fundamental feature like this (syncing of annotations).
Reply 

#6  santoshdts 08-28-2019, 03:00 PM
Quote binone
You are right!

I did the process very carefully this time and the annotations (highlights) did transfer over correctly to the same book on the second device. Existing annotations on the receiving device were also preserved.

Sweet.

I am not sure why it did not appear to work the first time I tried.

So the only (future) ask then is to have a way to transfer these via icloud.

Thanks again for taking the time to respond and for a great app.
Hi, Iam unable to sync the annotations to my other devices, as mentioned in earlier posts.
Could you please elaborate on the procedure on Marvin 3.1.2

Regards,
Reply 

Today's Posts | Search this Thread | Login | Register